Story Editorial Review
Story review

Review work after prose exists: editorial review, craft critique, continuity/voice review, copyediting, proofreading, and synthesis of reader-sim signal. Load when diagnosing a draft rather than rewriting it.
--- name: story-review description: | Review work after prose exists: editorial review, craft critique, continuity/voice review, copyediting, proofreading, and synthesis of reader-sim signal. Load when diagnosing a draft rather than rewriting it. --- # Story Review Analytical review of existing prose. This skill is for diagnosis, not rewriting. Keep `/reader-sim` separate when the task needs a felt first-time reader experience rather than analytical critique. Choose the review level before reading. Start big before small unless the caller explicitly asks for a late-stage pass. The edit levels move from structural to surface, and each assumes the levels above it are stable: - **Editorial review** — holistic third-party book-editor pass. What kind of revision does this draft need, and in what order?
Overview
Analytical review of existing prose. This skill is for diagnosis, not rewriting. Keep /reader-sim separate when the task needs a felt first-time reader experience rather than analytical critique.
Manual install (npx, ZIP)
npx skills add haowjy/creative-writing-skills --skill story-review -g -a claude-codenpx degit haowjy/creative-writing-skills/cw/skills/story-review#main ~/.claude/skills/story-reviewConnects with Agent Alley MCP · agentalley.io/mcp
Files included
SKILL.md1.8 KB
Read SKILL.md here
Show the full text43 lines
Story Review
Analytical review of existing prose. This skill is for diagnosis, not
rewriting. Keep /reader-sim separate when the task needs a felt first-time
reader experience rather than analytical critique.
Choose the review level before reading. Start big before small unless the caller explicitly asks for a late-stage pass. The edit levels move from structural to surface, and each assumes the levels above it are stable:
- Editorial review — holistic third-party book-editor pass. What kind of revision does this draft need, and in what order?
- Developmental edit — structure, promise, causality, pacing, character arc. Is the draft the right shape?
- Line edit — voice, rhythm, clarity, texture. Does the prose move well?
- Copyedit — grammar, usage, punctuation, consistency. Is it correct?
- Proofreading — final surface pass. What slipped through?
Each level has a dedicated resource with method and checklist:
resources/editorial-review.mdresources/developmental-edit.mdresources/line-edit.mdresources/copyedit.mdresources/proofreading.md
For adversarial craft critique (as opposed to editorial review), load:
resources/prose-critique.md— methodology and focus-area routing.resources/prose-critique/— deep resources per focus area (structure, character, voice, prose, continuity).
When review incorporates reader-sim data:
resources/reader-sim-signal.md— how to interpret and synthesize reader-sim output alongside analytical critique.
| 1 | |
| 2 | name story-review |
| 3 | description | |
| 4 | Review work after prose exists: editorial review, craft critique, continuity/voice review, copyediting, proofreading, and synthesis of reader-sim signal. Load when diagnosing a draft rather than rewriting it. |
| 5 | |
| 6 | |
| 7 | # Story Review |
| 8 | |
| 9 | Analytical review of existing prose. This skill is for diagnosis, not |
| 10 | rewriting. Keep `/reader-sim` separate when the task needs a felt first-time |
| 11 | reader experience rather than analytical critique. |
| 12 | |
| 13 | Choose the review level before reading. Start big before small unless the |
| 14 | caller explicitly asks for a late-stage pass. The edit levels move from |
| 15 | structural to surface, and each assumes the levels above it are stable: |
| 16 | |
| 17 | **Editorial review** — holistic third-party book-editor pass. What kind of |
| 18 | revision does this draft need, and in what order? |
| 19 | **Developmental edit** — structure, promise, causality, pacing, character |
| 20 | arc. Is the draft the right shape? |
| 21 | **Line edit** — voice, rhythm, clarity, texture. Does the prose move well? |
| 22 | **Copyedit** — grammar, usage, punctuation, consistency. Is it correct? |
| 23 | **Proofreading** — final surface pass. What slipped through? |
| 24 | |
| 25 | Each level has a dedicated resource with method and checklist: |
| 26 | |
| 27 | `resources/editorial-review.md` |
| 28 | `resources/developmental-edit.md` |
| 29 | `resources/line-edit.md` |
| 30 | `resources/copyedit.md` |
| 31 | `resources/proofreading.md` |
| 32 | |
| 33 | For adversarial craft critique (as opposed to editorial review), load: |
| 34 | |
| 35 | `resources/prose-critique.md` — methodology and focus-area routing. |
| 36 | `resources/prose-critique/` — deep resources per focus area (structure, |
| 37 | character, voice, prose, continuity). |
| 38 | |
| 39 | When review incorporates reader-sim data: |
| 40 | |
| 41 | `resources/reader-sim-signal.md` — how to interpret and synthesize |
| 42 | reader-sim output alongside analytical critique. |
| 43 |
Details
- License
- Apache-2.0
- Stars on the repo
- ★ 506
- Checked
- Source
- haowjy/creative-writing-skills ↗
- Creator
- haowjy · 22 listings
Similar skills
See all →
Cross-Platform Reverse Engineer
Brainstorm Ideas
Code Review Feedback Analyzer
Bug Diagnosis Framework
Implement Spec
PR Description WriterMore from haowjy
Character Voice Simulator
Story Research Assistant
Fiction Writing Craft Guide
Writing Mode Guide
Multi-Mode Writing Studio
Output Information Hierarchy